This is not a citation or impact factor ranking. It's just a ranking of where I find it most likely that an interesting paper will appear. The rating is about the right tail: journals which publish some garbage and some great stuff will rank (for me, in this personal ranking) higher than others which generally publish good stuff. In advance: No, I'm not Ivo. I'm a tenured MRM with about a dozen good pubs in a dozen years. No econ pubs, but nothing outside this list either.
1) Critical Finance Review
2) AER & QJE
4) ReStud & Econometrica
6) JFE (high variance, with a lot of data-mined junk but some very original stuff)
7) JPE
8) RFS
9) JF (low variance, but much of it boring)
10) RAPS
11) JET
12) JFQA
13) RCFS
14) Management Science
15) The others (sorry RoF, you'll get in here eventually, but I can't think of the last time I saw an interesting paper...)